Latest Stories


More than 40 million patent documents have been published, with almost a million new disclosures added each year. Patent searching is done to determine patentability of a new invention or the validity of an existing patent. Other reasons include clearing or determining infringement risks involved in commercializing a new product. Often a patent search is performed to find the state of the art or the direction of an existing technology to get guidance for research and development as well as innovations going off patent. Such information can be invaluable in today’s innovation driven world. Patent searches are performed through a number of free and paid databases hosted by various patent office, commercial and non-commercial entities throughout the world according to the objective of the search.
Patent Search
Patent search can be defined as a process of retrieving and analyzing prior art inventions based on various parameters from patent databases depending on the goals to be achieved.
1.    Types of Patent Search
          A.   Novelty Search: 
  • To determine novelty of new invention.

          B.  Freedom to operate Search
  • To determine extent of commercialization without infringement.
  • Also referred to as a “Clearance” search, a “right to use” search, or an “infringement” search.

          C.  Validity Search
  • Determine validity of a patent.

          D. State-of-the art Search
  •  To determine technology trend.

          Benefits from Patent Search
  • Identify innovation trends and developments in a specified field of technology
  • —Discover new product portfolio which can be licensed from the patentee or used without needing a license
  • —Find information that prevents duplication of research
  • —Keep track of the work of a particular individual or company by seeing what patents they have been granted i.e. obtain product information on your competitors.
  • —Find a solution to a technical problem
  • —Gain new ideas for research in a particular field

1.2.        Limitations of Patent Search
  • —Patents typically publish 18 months after the initial filing date so till that time they remains out of public domain
  • —Data is entered manually by patent offices and inevitably errors and inaccuracies will occur such as misindexing, misclassification and spelling errors
  • —Terms used in patents have technical meanings that are different from their everyday meanings
  • —Patent examiners may not classify a patent application into the most appropriate classifications
  • —An organization may have changed their name or acquired patents via purchasing or licensing.

2.    Developing a Patent Search Strategy
Which search tools to use?
◦       Various search type
–   Simple or Basic
–   Advanced or Syntax
–   Boolean or Field Combination
◦       Words (synonyms, some are more likely to be in the text than others)
–   Pros: Easy to use, Can be used in most databases, Infinitely flexible, Can be use singly or in specified combinations/ orders/ separations, Can search full text in some databases or restrict to titles/abstracts/abstracts.
–   Cons: Need to be aware of language, synonyms (e.g. cellphone, cell phone, mobile phone), Alternative spellings (e.g US v UK, color and colour), Can be imprecise in some arts and generate too many hits (e.g. for electric circuits - control AND temperature).
◦       Classifications e.g. IPC, US
–   Pros: Independent of language, synonyms, alternative spellings, terminology, quirky vocabulary, Comprehensive and detailed, Classification term can be the quickest and best way.
–   Cons: Can be complex and challenging to understand beyond an elementary level, May not have any terms which are a good fit for a particular search, May be applied with varying skill and accuracy by different authorities, May generate too many hits if used at a general level, May not be universally applied.
◦       Names e.g. Inventor
◦       Dates
◦       Citations
Which fields to search?
◦       Patent Office
◦       Title
◦       Abstract
◦       Claims
◦       Full Text
◦       Bibliographic Data

3.    Refining Search-Trial & Error
◦       Try in individual or combined search in different parts of patent e.g. title,  abstract, claims etc.
◦       Try searching as a phrase
◦       Use different Operator e.g. AND, OR, or ANDNOT etc.
◦       Use a truncation wildcard "$" or “*” e.g. Mot$ , US2000*
◦       On/Off  word stemming
◦       Include/Exclude synonyms
◦       Expand/Shrink abbreviations
◦       Increase/ Decrease time bracket

4.    Patent Search Resources
◦       Patent  Office Database Search
–   WIPO Patentscope
–   USPTO(United State Patent and Trademark Office)
–   EPO(European Patent office)
–   Patent Abstracts of Japan
–   CIPO(Canadian IP Office)…..many more
◦       On-line Patent Office Databse Search Services
–   Free Databases
—  Patent Lens
—  SIP Patent Database
—  Free patents online
—  Sumobrain
—  PriorIP…..many more
–   Paid Databases
—  Delphion
—  Q-Pat
—  Boliven
—  Patsnap …..many more
◦       Patent Search Softwares
–   Patent integration
–   IP vision
–   Patent Insight Pro….. many more


Conclusion

A patent search is a crucial step to take before filing a patent application. Just as you need to do due diligence before taking on any business venture, you need to do your patent landscaping before filing a patent application. A patent search involves tedious, repeated searching through various patent and non-patent literatures using typical technical words. An unskilled person would not be able to do justice to the vast amount of literature to be searched. A patent professional, who is acquainted with better patent landscaping capabilities, can analyze your invention from the perspective of a patent examiner. Furthermore, there are ways to structure a patent application differently to make your invention fit for patentability. Since patenting is a skilled expensive procedure, it is prudent to conduct a patentability search before filing an application. Besides financial reasons, there are several other compelling reasons as discussed for conducting a search before filing an application.
Read More ...

Latest Stories


Hi IP MADs,


History

The Olympic Games are considered to be the world's foremost sports competition and more than 200 nations participate. The Games are currently held biennially, with summer and Winter Olympic Games alternating, meaning they occur every four years within their respective seasonal games. Originally, the ancient Olympic Games were held in Olympia, Greece, from the 8th century BC to the 4th century AD. Baron Pierre de Coubertin founded the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in 1894. The IOC has since become the governing body of the Olympic Movement, whose structure and actions are defined by the Olympic Charter.[i]

Intellectual Property

In the recent edition of WIPO Magazine IP article entitled “The Olympic Properties” (By Marianne Chappuis, Trademark Legal Counsel, International Olympic Committee) explored how the International Olympic Committee (IOC) protects the visual symbols of the Olympic Games, the so-called Olympic properties that are so familiar. The Olympic symbol, seen by millions of people throughout the Olympic Games, is one of the world’s most recognized brands. The five interlocking rings represent the coming together of five continents and symbolize the Olympic values: striving for excellence, demonstrating respect and celebrating friendship. The Olympic properties have become iconic – they are more than just “logos”. People around the world associate them with the fundamental Values of sport and of the Olympic Movement. According to a survey in 2001, the Olympic Rings are the most recognised symbol in the world with unaided brand awareness of 93%.[ii]

Iconic Olympic symbol enjoys special protection under the Nairobi Treaty on the Protection of the Olympic Symbol. States that have signed up to the Treaty are obliged to refuse or invalidate the registration as a mark and to prohibit the use for commercial purposes of any sign consisting of or  containing the Olympic symbol, except with the IOC ’s authorization. The Olympic Charter is the codification of the Fundamental Principles of Olympism, Rules and Bye-Laws adopted by the IOC. According to Rule 7 of the Charter, the Olympic properties include the Olympic symbol as well as the Olympic flag, motto, anthem, identifiers (such as “Olympic Games” and “Games of the Olympiad”), designations, emblems, the Olympic flame and torches. All rights to any and all Olympic properties belong exclusively to the IOC, including rights to their use such as in relation to profit-making, commercial or advertising purposes.

Why Intellectual Property Protection Is Required For Olympic Games?

Support from the business community is crucial to the holding of the Olympic Games, one of the most effective international marketing platforms in the world, reaching billions of people in more than 200 countries and territories across the globe. The IOC distributes more than 90 percent of its revenues to organizations throughout the Olympic Movement to support the staging of the Olympic Games and to promote the development of sport worldwide. The IOC’s worldwide sponsorship program, The Olympic Partner (TOP) Programme, was established to enable long-term corporate partnerships of benefit to the Olympic Movement. The TOP Programme provides each worldwide partner with exclusive global marketing rights and opportunities within a designated product or service category. Consequently, the IOC must be able to protect the exclusivity granted to its broadcast and marketing partners, and therefore needs to have the necessary means to prevent third parties from making any unauthorized association with the Olympic Games. The role of branding in London 2012 written by Ray Vellest  a London-based brand identity designer gives excellent coverage on branding & raising awareness for Olympic properties.

How Intellectual Property Protection Is Enabled For Olympic Games?

Numerous countries have adopted permanent national legislation protecting the Olympic properties. Although the Olympic Movement’s efforts have contributed to the implementation of legislation, the parliaments that have adopted such measures also understand the importance of sport and the Olympic Movement, as well as the need to protect the properties related to them.

Adopting specific legislation has also proven necessary in countries that host an edition of the Olympic Games. Such legislation concerns not only the protection of the Olympic properties, but also provides the means to fight against ambush marketing and to regulate advertising, in particular in and around Olympic venues. The first specific legislation related to an edition of the Olympic Games appeared in Canada prior to the Montreal 1976 Olympic Games. Since the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games, all host countries have adopted such legislation; this is also true for future editions of the Olympic Games, such as Sochi 2014 and Rio 2016.  In the UK, the London Olympic and Paralympic Games Act 2006 (The London Olympics Act) lays down much of the law to prevent the unauthorized commercial exploitation of these valuable rights.

In relation to the London 2012 Olympic Games, the UK Parliament has adopted the London Olympic and Paralympic Act. This legislation extends legal protection to all properties associated with the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games. Moreover, it forbids any entity from associating itself, or its products or services, with the Olympic Games to gain a commercial advantage, unless expressly authorized to do so by the London 2012 Organizing Committee (LOCOG). The law also provides local authorities and LOCOG with the means to fight ambush marketing efficiently, and to prevent the unauthorized sale of Olympic tickets and other ambush marketing activities at an Olympic venue or in the air space surrounding it.

The Nairobi Treaty

The IOC also benefits from an exceptional international legal instrument that protects the Olympic symbol. Adopted in 1981 and administered by WIPO, the Nairobi Treaty on the Protection of the Olympic Symbol obliges each state that has ratified it to refuse or invalidate the registration as a mark and to prohibit the use for commercial purposes of any sign consisting of or containing the Olympic symbol, except with the IOC’s authorization.

Trademark protection
The IOC is the worldwide owner of numerous trademarks protecting its Olympic properties. While this might seem logical, the IOC had to wait some 100 years before it could register trademarks in its own name. Prior to 1993, numerous national trademark laws (including in Switzerland, where the IOC is based) reserved the right to register trademarks only for commercial companies. As a non-profit association, the IOC had to wait for the harmonization of European law and the modification of Swiss law such that any entity could register a trademark in its name.

The IOC registers trademarks, in particular through the WIPO Madrid system, relating to its permanent properties (which are common to each edition of the Olympic Games), such as the Olympic symbol and the words “Olympic”, “Olympiad” and “Olympic Games”. It also seeks protection for identifiers related to a specific edition of the Olympic Games, such as the official emblem of that edition of the Olympic Games and the City+Year word mark - for example, “London 2012” and “Sochi 2014”. Logos from the summer and winter Olympic Games from 1924 to 2012 can be found here. Below is the list of trademarks (active registrations, applications/requests being processed, registrations no longer in force):
Implementing the IOC’s rights

In the routine management of its intellectual property (IP) rights, the IOC encounters certain challenges, some of which are described below.

1.     Internet and social media platforms

Internet and social media platforms are fantastic opportunities to engage new audiences, especially the young. The IOC is embracing this opportunity and has a presence on several major social media platforms. However, from an IP point of view, it is important for the IOC, like other trademark owners, to control the use of its properties on such platforms, in particular in relation to the numerous possibilities for third parties to make unauthorized use of Olympic properties. The IOC works closely with social media platforms to prevent unauthorized use of its properties. It also closely follows the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) project, opening the door to new extensions of top level domain names, in order to protect its Olympic properties on the Internet.

2.     Ambush marketing

Ambush marketing consists of attempts to create a false, unauthorized or misleading commercial association with the Olympic Movement or the Olympic Games. It includes a third party’s use of creative means to generate a false association with the Olympic Movement or Olympic Games; infringement of the various laws that protect the use of Olympic properties; and interference with the legitimate marketing activities of Olympic partners. Some companies that are not official partners try to associate themselves with the unique and worldwide character of the Olympic Games free of charge. This is unfair vis-à-vis companies that financially support the Olympic Games as well as to the participating athletes. The creativity of these ambushers makes it necessary to adopt specific national legislation to prevent ambush marketing. However, as these laws are in force only in the host territory, the IOC must invoke, in other territories, ordinary legal means to fight ambush marketing, such as trademark registration or unfair competition. However, these sometimes do not go as far as the IOC would like.

3.     Protection of the City+Year word mark

In 1993, before Sydney was elected to host the 2000 Olympic Games, a third party filed for registration of all the names of the candidate cities for the 2000 Olympic Games, in numerous countries, and then threatened the IOC partners with legal action if they used these references. To prevent such abuses in the future, the IOC subsequently took steps to protect the City+Year identifiers, well before a city is selected to host an edition of the Olympic Games.

Some court decisions, however, have called into question the distinctive character of a trademark composed of a city and a year. The distinctive character of a mark acquired after its lengthy use is a known remedy for an initial potential lack of distinctiveness. However, numerous trademark offices around the world accept that, in the specific case of the Olympic Games, and given the exceptional worldwide interest in, and media coverage of, a city’s election by the IOC, distinctiveness is acquired the moment the result is announced. It is widely recognized that the “City+Year” identification of the Olympic Games immediately gains considerable notoriety and continues to increase in attractiveness and distinctiveness, peaking during the actual holding of the Olympic Games.

The Olympic Games are one of the most well-known sporting events in the world. Protecting the Olympic properties is, therefore, very important. The IOC benefits from a privileged situation thanks to the existence of the Nairobi Treaty, as well as national legislation to protect the Olympic properties and combat ambush marketing in certain territories. However, ordinary legal protection, such as trademark protection, remains essential. Like many other trademark owners, including sports governing bodies, the IOC faces a number of new challenges in managing its IP, in particular in relation to social media platforms.

While the IOC considers the advent of social media an opportunity for sports bodies to engage new generations of fans and participants, it must face the new challenges they pose in terms of managing the Olympic properties. Close collaboration with the providers of these services, will undoubtedly go a long way in mitigating this risk. Judicious management of the Olympic properties will help ensure that people of all ages and from all continents can continue to take part in the spectacle and celebrate the values that underpin the Olympic Games for generations to come. The list of registered trademark for “London 2012” can be seen here.

Designing  excellence

The Torch, designed by studio Barber Osgerby, was chosen from 89 entries to claim the winning title. Made of aluminium, it will be carried over 8,000 miles over the course of its 70-day Torch Relay, and is perforated with 8,000 circular holes representing the 8,000 Torchbearers. Aside from being decorative, the holes also help reduce the weight of the torch and prevent heat conduction.

The London 2012 Velodrome on the Olympic Park also won the Architecture Award. The Velodrome is one of the most sustainable and iconic venues of the Games. Sebastian Coe, Chair of the London 2012 Organising Committee, said: ‘The Torch is one of the most recognisable symbols of the Olympic Games and we are thrilled that our design has won this prestigious title. I am delighted we have such a brilliantly designed, engineered and crafted Torch that will help to celebrate the amazing personal achievements of each of our 8,000 Torchbearers and give them their moment to shine.'It is also fantastic news that the stunning architecture of the London 2012 Velodrome has won an award and welcome recognition of the landmark new buildings the Games are bringing to London.’ Deyan Sudjic, Director of the Design Museum, said of the winning entry: ‘Nothing is harder to get right than designing for the Olympics. The lightness and simplicity of Barber Osgerby’s London 2012 Olympic Torch does just that. The Torch not only captures the spirit of London as Olympic Host City but also demonstrates how design can celebrate traditional ideas in a modern way.’


Tune into http://www.london2012.com/ for result updates.

[ii] AM Wall The Game behind the Games, 91 Trade Mark Rep.1243 (2001).


Read More ...

Latest Stories

Hi IP MADs,

Background: What is driving Indian water purifier segment?
In the past few years, Indian water purifier industry has witnessed an exponential growth of more than 22% CAGR. According to TechSci Research, the water purifier industry sales grew dramatically during FY’10 as compared to previous fiscals due to improving demand and expanding production capacity. In 2011, the organized water purifier market stood at Rs 1500 Crore. Given the increasing awareness, and largely untapped market potential, the sector is expected to grow at a CAGR of more than 20 percent till 2016. As per India Water Review, water purifier segment is growing at a compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of about 25 per cent and is likely to touch Rs 7,000 crore by 2015 from the current level of about Rs 3,200 crore as of June 2, 2012.
HUL launched its Pureit water purifier range in India in 2008 with patent protection or market exclusivity for its gravity-fed filtration technology. The water purifier currently sells around six million units per annum, contributing about Rs. 200-250 crore to its annual revenue.
‘Tata Swach’- World’s most cost-effective water purifier improves affordability of safe drinking water for millions of families. It is innovative nanotechnology water purifier made from rick husk ash which does not require electricity or running water to operate. The product development has resulted in 14 patents being filed by the company.

India’s apex Intellectual Property tribunal i.e. Intellectual Property Appellate Board (IPAB) on 12th June, 2012 has ruled that the patent issued to Hindustan Unilever Ltd’s (HUL) in 2005 has been revoked with cost of Rs.5000/-,marking a landmark victory for the Tata group in a high profile intellectual property battle.
The Applicant, Tata Chemicals Limited sought revocation of the invention of Patent No.195937 (Application No. 709/MUM/2002) titled “Filter Device” filed on August 7, 2002 and granted on August 26, 2005 to Hindustan Unilever Limited. The Invention relates to a filter cartridge for use in gravity-fed filtration “in particular to a novel filter cartridge which would facilitate gravity flow filtration at constant flow rate even with increased literage of water through the cartridge maintaining effective filtration characteristics”.

Interesting because of the grounds on which HUL’s patent has been revoked!!
The IPAB order in this high-profile intellectual property dispute is significant because it is the first such decision in which suppression of details and submission of incorrect filings attracting the provisions of Section 8 of the Indian Patent Act, 1970 were the basis for the cancellation of a patent. In support of the grounds relied by the Applicant attacking the patent as being anticipated, and obvious and insufficiently described and so on, they relied upon the following patent documents. In addition both the parties have relied upon plethora of foreign case laws.

No.
Used to Prove
Document Number
Filing Date
Title
1
Prior art-Hindustan Unilever
December 17, 1992
Ceramic filter
2
Prior art-Hindustan Unilever
October 12, 1994
Gravity water purifier
3
Prior art-Indian Patent Office
December 2, 2000
Water filtration apparatus
4
Invention lacks novelty and inventive step
December 2, 2001
Water filtration apparatus
5
Invention lacks novelty and inventive step
August 20, 1998
Filtration Device for Liquid Purification
6
Obviousness
April 13, 1972
Water Purification Device
7
Lacking inventive step
February 13, 1979
Filter

The table below will show how the Invention is fully taught by US‘260.   The terminology is different, but the hollow passage is there, the upward flow of fluid through the filter media is there and how they are constructed is the same. 

 Many arguments were made from both the sides alleging requirements of Section 8 of the Indian Patent Act, 1970. It is interesting to note that the IPER (International Preliminary Examination Report) rejected the claims 1 to 3 on both the grounds of novelty and inventive step. The Patent Office did not see the IPER as it was not submitted. In paragraph 107 of the order it was laid down that, “The Act requires compliance with Section 8(1) and 8(2) and the patent applicant must comply with the same.  Otherwise the patent is liable to be revoked.”

One of the most conspicuous part of the pronounced order is in paragraph 110 which highlights “essence of expert evidence and its role in development of IP jurisprudence” as hereunder:
We find as a rule the experts called upon by the parties before us file affidavits.  These affidavits are naturally drafted by the respective advocates.  So they read almost like the statement of case or counter statement depending on who has called the witness.  Instead it may be better to just get their opinion in the form of an affidavit.  This opinion will deal with the prior art, the common general knowledge, this invention and why the expert is of the opinion that it is anticipated or not, it is obvious or not.  Even when the affidavit has to counter the opinion of the other side expert, it is better merely to say that the expert disagrees with the opinion and for what reason.  Instead the affidavits contain attacks on the expertise of the experts.  This must be eschewed.  Each expert gives his opinion and the reasons therefore and the Court / Board will apply its mind and decide how relevant the evidence is for proving the case.  The experts are respected academicians in their fields and such attacks may discourage the best minds from offering to assist us. It will be then a loss to the development of IP jurisprudence. The expert evidence is one of the relevant facts which the court has to consider and while deciding the patentability of some inventions, this may be very crucial.  We hope the members of the Bar will bear this in mind, when they request experts to assist us.  Whether they appear in the witness box or file affidavits in lieu thereof, the witnesses deserve our respect.

For more information please follow "Mad 4 IP"

     

Read More ...

Latest Stories

Hi IP MADs,
The tobacco epidemic is one of the biggest public health threats the world has ever faced. Present and future generations must be urgently protected from the devastating health, social, environmental and economic consequences of tobacco consumption and exposure to tobacco smoke. The costs of tobacco use are measured in its enormous toll of disease, suffering and family distress. Economies also suffer from increased health-care costs and decreased productivity.


Tobacco Key facts

Ø  Tobacco kills up to half of its users.
Ø  Tobacco kills nearly six million people each year, of which more than 5 million are users and ex users and more than 600000 are nonsmokers exposed to second-hand smoke. Unless urgent action is taken, the annual death toll could rise to more than eight million by 2030.
Ø  Nearly 80% of the world's one billion smokers live in low- and middle-income countries.
Ø  Consumption of tobacco products is increasing globally, though it is decreasing in some high-income and upper middle-income countries.

WHO is committed to fight the global tobacco epidemic. The WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control entered into force in February 2005. Since then, it has become one of the most widely embraced treaties in the history of the United Nations with more than 170 Parties covering 87% of the world's population. Tobacco industry interference is the theme of this year’s World No Tobacco Day, which takes place on 31 May 2012.The campaign will focus on the need to expose and counter the tobacco industry's brazen and increasingly aggressive attempts to undermine global tobacco control efforts.
Vapor Corporation, a leading U.S. based electronic cigarette company, announced that on June 5, 2012, it has filed a non-provisional patent for a "Padded Cartridge For An Electronic Cigarette Apparatus" based on Vapor's previously filed provisional patent application, as filed with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office on June 7, 2011. Vapor Corp.'s Soft Padded Electronic Cigarette Cartridge is a soft tip filter with the same tactile feel of a traditional cigarette filter.
"We believe the soft padded electronic cartridge is the most significant innovation to e-cigarettes, since their invention and introduction to the US marketplace," said Kevin Frija, CEO of Vapor. "We constantly strive to enhance the experience and comfort for those who use and enjoy our products.  The comfort of the new soft tip filter will offer our customers the most realistic and similar experience akin to the filters of traditional cigarettes. We are truly excited to offer this unique remarkable advancement to our customers, and we plan to launch electronic cigarettes with these soft tip filters by year end to our on-line customers, and then roll out the product offerings brand by brand and company-wide in 2013."
It is happy to know that such intellectual property driven efforts are doing the needful to combat with the evil of tobacco epidemic. Another point I would like to mention is that patent offices should go for fast track prosecution of inventions for which society is craving, isn’t it?

References:
  1. Image source: http://www.who.int/tobacco/wntd/2012/en/index.html
  2. http://www.who.int/tobacco/control/en/
  3.  http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs339/en/index.html
  4.  http://www.who.int/tobacco/en/index.html
  5.  http://www.who.int/tobacco/economics/en/
  6.  
    http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/vapor-corp-filed-patent-application-for-soft-padded-electronic-cigarette-cartridge-157786775.html
  7. Vapor Corp. website: http://www.vapor-corp.com/index.php

For more information please follow "Mad 4 IP"


    
Read More ...